Mind Dump

The education reform debate as we have known it is creaking to a halt

The education-reform debate as we have known it for a generation is creaking to a halt. No new way of thinking has emerged to displace those that have preoccupied reformers for a quarter-­century — but the defining ideas of our current wave of reform (­standards, testing, and choice), and the conceptual framework built around them, are clearly outliving their usefulness.

The problem is not that these ideas are misguided. Rather, they are just not powerful enough to force the rusty infrastructure of American primary and secondary education to undergo meaningful change. They have failed at bringing about the reformers' most important goal: dramatically improved student achievement.

The next wave of education policy will therefore need to direct itself toward even more fundamental questions, challenging long-held ­assumptions about how education is managed, funded, designed, and overseen.

Found via http://www.edexcellence.net/flypaper/index.php/2009/12/the-end-of-the-education-debate

2 comments

Dec 16, 2009
Terry Smith said...
Scott - to "challenging long-held ­assumptions about how education is managed, funded, designed, and overseen." I would add challenging the basic ideas of how learning happens, i.e. just teaching it doesn't mean it is being learned. Lots of great research on learning out there that doesn't seem to be known or heeded by public education.
Dec 16, 2009
Christine Geith said...
Scott, as you say, the reform variables of "standards, testing and choice" haven't been enough to move us out of our current assumptions. I've been pondering the framing of the problem in the first place, and suggest in the post I did tonight http://bit.ly/8oVRf3 that we need new design requirements to "get us off the bus" so to speak.

Leave a comment...

?