Mind Dump

Knowledge and expertise are changing

In a world too big to know™, our basic strategy has been to filter, reduce, and fragment knowledge. This was true all the way through the Information Age. Our fear of information overload now seems antiquated. Not only is there “no such thing as information overload, only filter failure” Clay Shirky, natch, in the digital age, the nature of filters change. On the Net, we do not filter out. We filter forward. That is, on the Net, a filter merely shortens the number of clicks it takes to get to an object; all the other objects remain accessible.

This changes the role and nature of expertise, and of knowledge itself. For traditional knowledge is a system of stopping points for inquiry. This is very efficient, but its based on the limitations of paper as knowledges medium. Indeed, science itself has viewed itself as a type of publishing: It is done in private and not made public until its certain-ish.

But the networking of knowledge gives us a new strategy. We will continue to use the old one where appropriate. Networked knowledge is abundant, unsettled, never done, public, imperfect, and contains disagreements within itself.

2 comments

Nov 26, 2010
Tina said...
Thinking outside the box has been the catch phrase for all creative thinking for quite some time. I like to to say instead 'think inside the brain' which to me means exactly what you are talking about in this post. It means let the brain tell us what it needs for learning in these times with all the technology and information that surrounds us. It is a different learning model and we have just started identifying how to use all of it.
Nov 27, 2010
Mohan Arun L said...
"The technology utopians tell us that the problem is not too much information. What we need are better filters, better ways to search. That’s like saying we need a better alternative to oil. Yes, absolutely, but right now we don’t have that better alternative. We can’t just wait around for the better filters to arrive.

The other problem with the better filter approach is poor quality information. If the information is out of date or plain wrong, then how do you filter it? If the information is badly written and confusing, then how do you filter that? If the information is badly organized and has no metadata then how do you filter that? Filters are not magical." - Gerry McGovern

Leave a comment...

? ? ?